Miami Dolphins’ Blockbuster Trade for Myles Garrett: Could a Deal Be in the Works?
Introduction
The NFL offseason is always full of surprises, and one of the latest bombshells is the rumor surrounding Cleveland Browns star pass rusher Myles Garrett. Reports suggest that Garrett may have requested a trade, and speculation has already begun about potential landing spots. Among the teams that could make a serious move for the All-Pro defensive end are the Miami Dolphins.
The Dolphins, already boasting a strong roster, could view Garrett as the missing piece to take their defense to the next level. But what would it take to land him? And how would this blockbuster trade impact both teams? Let’s break down the details, trade possibilities, and implications for Miami and Cleveland.
Myles Garrett’s Trade Request: Fact or Fiction?
Myles Garrett has been the heart and soul of the Browns’ defense since being selected as the No. 1 overall pick in the 2017 NFL Draft. The former Defensive Player of the Year candidate has consistently been among the league’s best pass rushers, racking up sacks, forcing turnovers, and disrupting offenses with his elite athleticism and power.
However, rumors have surfaced that Garrett may have requested a trade due to frustration with the Browns’ direction. Whether it’s dissatisfaction with the coaching staff, internal team issues, or simply wanting a fresh start, the possibility of Garrett being on the move is enough to send shockwaves through the league.
Cleveland, while a competitive team, has faced playoff struggles and quarterback uncertainties. If Garrett is indeed seeking a trade, the Browns could explore the market for a deal that brings them significant draft capital or impact players in return.
Why the Dolphins Make Sense for Myles Garrett
The Miami Dolphins have been aggressive in building a championship-caliber roster under head coach Mike McDaniel. With an explosive offense led by quarterback Tua Tagovailoa and star playmakers like Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle, Miami’s offense is one of the most dangerous in the NFL. However, their defense has been inconsistent, especially with injuries affecting key players like Jaelan Phillips and Bradley Chubb.
Adding Myles Garrett would instantly transform Miami’s defense into one of the most formidable units in the league. Here’s why the Dolphins should strongly consider making a move for him:
1. Pass Rush Dominance
Miami already has talent on the defensive line, but Garrett would elevate it to another level. Pairing him with Chubb (once healthy) and Phillips would create a nightmare for opposing quarterbacks. With the Dolphins competing in a division that features Josh Allen and a potentially revamped Aaron Rodgers-led Jets offense, having an elite pass rush is crucial.
2. Win-Now Mode
The Dolphins are built to win now. With key players in their prime and Tua’s contract situation looming, Miami has a short window to make a Super Bowl run before major financial decisions reshape the roster. Acquiring Garrett would be a bold move signaling that they are all-in on competing for a championship immediately.
3. Defensive Consistency
Miami’s defense showed flashes of brilliance last season but lacked consistency. Adding Garrett would give them a game-wrecker who can change the course of games with sacks, forced fumbles, and relentless pressure. A dominant defensive front would also ease the burden on Miami’s secondary, which has struggled with injuries.
What Would a Myles Garrett Trade Look Like?
Landing a player of Myles Garrett’s caliber won’t be cheap. The Browns will demand significant compensation, likely in the form of draft picks and possibly a player in return. Here are a few potential trade scenarios:
Trade Package 1: High Draft Capital Deal
Dolphins receive:
- DE Myles Garrett
Browns receive:
- 2025 First-Round Pick
- 2026 First-Round Pick
- 2025 Third-Round Pick
This trade would give Cleveland valuable draft capital to rebuild their defense and address other needs while allowing Miami to add a premier talent. The downside for the Dolphins would be sacrificing future picks, but if they believe Garrett can be the difference-maker, it might be worth it.
Trade Package 2: Player + Picks Package
Dolphins receive:
- DE Myles Garrett
Browns receive:
- EDGE Jaelan Phillips
- 2025 First-Round Pick
- 2026 Second-Round Pick
This deal would soften the blow for Cleveland by giving them an immediate impact player in Phillips, who has shown tremendous potential. While Miami wouldn’t want to part with Phillips, adding Garrett could justify the move, especially with Chubb still in the mix.
Trade Package 3: All-in Blockbuster Deal
Dolphins receive:
- DE Myles Garrett
- 2025 Fourth-Round Pick
Browns receive:
- 2025 First-Round Pick
- 2026 First-Round Pick
- CB Xavien Howard
- 2025 Third-Round Pick
This deal would require Miami to part with veteran cornerback Xavien Howard, who has been a key piece of their secondary. If the Dolphins believe their pass rush can compensate for losing Howard, this move could make sense.
How Would Garrett Fit in Miami?
Myles Garrett would be an immediate game-changer for the Dolphins. He fits perfectly in Vic Fangio’s defensive scheme (if Fangio stays), which prioritizes elite pass rushers who can generate pressure without heavy blitzing. If the Dolphins shift defensive coordinators, Garrett is versatile enough to excel in any system.
His presence would not only make life easier for Miami’s secondary but also allow defensive linemen like Christian Wilkins (if re-signed) and Zach Sieler to face fewer double teams. The combination of Garrett, Chubb, and Phillips would rival any defensive front in the league.
Challenges of the Trade
While acquiring Garrett sounds like a dream scenario, there are obstacles Miami would need to navigate:
- Salary Cap Considerations: Garrett carries a hefty contract, and Miami would need to restructure deals or move money around to fit him in.
- Depth Concerns: If the Dolphins part with Phillips or Howard in a trade, they may need to address other defensive positions in free agency or the draft.
- Chemistry and Scheme Fit: Any time a superstar joins a new team, there’s an adjustment period. However, given Garrett’s talent, he would likely fit in seamlessly.
Final Verdict: Will the Dolphins Make the Move?
A trade for Myles Garrett would be a massive, franchise-altering move for the Miami Dolphins. It would signal that they are fully committed to contending for a Super Bowl right now. However, it all depends on whether the Browns are truly willing to move on from Garrett and if Miami is prepared to pay the steep price.
If the rumors of Garrett’s trade request are true, Miami should at least explore the possibility. They have the draft capital and some intriguing trade pieces that could make a deal work. Whether or not they pull the trigger will come down to how aggressive the front office wants to be in their pursuit of a championship.
For now, Dolphins fans can dream about the possibility of Myles Garrett lining up in aqua and orange, terrorizing quarterbacks, and taking Miami’s defense to elite status. Whether or not it happens remains to be seen, but one thing is certain—the offseason is just getting started, and anything is possible in the NFL.
